The Echo Maker: A Novel The Echo Maker: A Novel by Richard Powers
My rating: 1 of 5 stars

I couldn’t finish this slow, overly descriptive, not-at-all intriguing, boring novel. It was a book-club pick and only two people finished it, one kicking and screaming.

The book is about a man in his mid-20s who’s in a car accident and spends two weeks in a coma. When he wakes up and begins his recovery, he accuses his sister – the two have always been very close – of being an impostor. It’s a disorder called Capgras syndrome, and it’s very rare.

The neuroscience and psychology in the book are fascinating. Imagine what it would be like to think the person or people you love the most have been replaced by replica robots, aliens or government agents. On the flip side, imagine if someone you love thought you were an impostor. That would right and royally suck.

And you know, the sister in the novel is pretty much a suck of a main character. Powers just dropped the ball on developing her beyond a whiny, scarred-from-childhood sot. He hints at why she’s that way but he doesn’t follow through (or maybe he does eventually, but I couldn’t get there). So instead of finding her sympathetic, I eventually just wanted to punch her in the face.

Anyway. Lots of novels are about extraordinary people. This novel is about ordinary people in an extraordinary circumstance to which neither the characters nor the writing stands up.

I found the writing maddeningly self-indulgent. The prose simply isn’t crafty, skilled or beautiful enough to warrant its quantity. The story concept is a good one, and the science is, as I said, fascinating. Unfortunately, the pacing just didn’t do them justice.

Save 400 pages of your time for another book – it’s almost certain to be more enjoyable.

Notify of

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kim Hennesey

I am so very pleased to have my buddy Sarah Bryars (she is Esssjay on LiveJournal, alcohol treatment center and @Esssjay on Twitter) helping me review some of Marcus Sedgwick's books. As you can tell by the small little advert on the right hand side of the blog, January 2010 is “Marcus Sedgwick Month” on MFB

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x